We live so much in polarities in our day to day lives, personal and political, that I thought it would be helpful to share this excerpt from Developmental Politics by Steve McIntosh.
Polarity Theory, An Introduction
Over the past few decades a promising theoretical perspective has arisen that sheds new light on the forces that cause polarization. This way to think about conflict, known as polarity theory, posits that certain types of polar opposition are actually generators of value that, when effectively managed, can build agreement and produce meaningful progress.9
While polar dichotomies are ubiquitous in human experience, most of these forms of opposition can be recognized as straightforwardly positive and negative. Prosperity and poverty, for example, is a kind of polar relationship that exists between a value and a disvalue. In a positive-negative opposition such as this, the positive pole represents our goal and the negative pole describes what we’re trying to avoid or overcome. Positive-negative polarities thus represent problems to be solved. Continuing with this example, even though poverty is a chronic human condition, it has been largely eradicated in some parts of the world. And I believe some day we may be able to eliminate it entirely. Although most polar dichotomies are of this positive-negative type, there is another, rarer form of polar opposition wherein both poles are essentially positive.
Unlike positive-negative forms of opposition, these positive-positive polarities are permanently recurring or indestructible, so they cannot be solved or laid to rest. An authentic positive-positive polarity is a kind of perpetual recursive system that can only be managed more or less well.
Examples of positive-positive polarities include: individual-community, liberty-equality, real-ideal, competition-cooperation, mercy-justice, freedom-order, challenge-support, relative-absolute, defense-offense, grievance-gratitude, simplicity-complexity, immanent-transcendent, and even masculine-feminine.
These permanently recurring polarities continue to show up in the course of human affairs because polar opposition is a fundamental feature of the dynamic behavior of value.
As explored further in Part II, values are energetic forces that naturally cohere in opposing pairs that are nevertheless interdependent. This interdependence can be seen in the way each pole uses the other to achieve its value-creating potential. In the pairs of polar values listed above, the strengths of each pole serve to mitigate and correct the downsides of its opposing pole in a recursive stepwise process that results in synergistic progress. Managing these relatively indestructible forms of opposition accordingly involves bringing out the best of both sides while avoiding the limits of each.
In the case of the competition-cooperation polarity, for example, unrestrained competition, in the absence of a larger agreement to play by the rules and cooperate, can quickly devolve into a dog-eat-dog condition wherein defensiveness saps productivity. Conversely, cooperation by itself, without the incentive or opportunity for individual excellence or creativity, can similarly devolve into groupthink or stifling bureaucratic mediocrity. But when competition and cooperation are brought together in a mutually correcting relationship that provides for both challenge and support, the value-creating potential of each side is maximized.
While polarity theory is fairly new, the mutual interdependence of positive opposites was realized as early as the sixth century B.C. And notably, this realization occurred independently yet relatively contemporaneously in both the East and the West, in the writing of the Chinese sage Lao Tzu and the Greek philosopher Heraclitus. The philosophical significance of this “coincidence of opposites” was also described by Nicholas of Cusa in the fifteenth century. The fact that many values cohere in complementary polar sets has even been recognized in the context of science by Nobel Prize-winning physicist Niels Bohr who wrote, “the opposite of a small truth is a falsehood, but the opposite of a great truth is another great truth.”10
However, as we discuss further in chapter 6, while positive-positive value polarities exhibit opposing yet interdependent relationships, their poles are not necessarily equal or otherwise perfectly balanced. Some polarities, such as masculine and feminine, are of course equal in most important respects. But even the most equal forms of positive-positive polarity invariably reflect the creative motif of part and whole. Indeed, even within the otherwise balanced equality of the masculine-feminine polarity, the characteristics of part and whole are nevertheless evident. This pattern of part and whole can be seen in personality traits commonly associated with each pole, and even in the physical form and function of male and female reproductive anatomy. As we will see, this creative motif of part and whole is the key to the generative or procreative capacity of these value-creating polar relationships.
A common mistake in human affairs generally, and politics in particular, is to confuse a positive-negative dichotomy, representing a problem to be solved, with a positive-positive polar system that needs to be continuously managed. Partisans on both the left and right, for instance, approach most political issues from a win-lose perspective wherein their side is seen as straightforwardly good and the opposition’s position is seen as simply bad or even evil. While some political issues are in fact unequivocal matters of right and wrong wherein one side needs to win and the other side needs to lose, most political conflicts are not of this kind. As the values charts introduced in the last section show, many political polarities arise from the competition between opposing values that are best recognized as different kinds of goods.
Recalling the geological strata analogy from the beginning of this chapter, we can acknowledge that in the context of politics, opposing interests are often irreconcilable—at the level of perceived interests we are often faced with a win-lose proposition. But when we approach political oppositions at the deeper level of bedrock values, the potential for compromise and reconciliation is greatly increased, especially when we appreciate the insights of polarity theory. The simple reason why values are easier to integrate than interests is that an authentic bedrock value is something that almost everyone already shares. Once we have clearly distinguished between the positives and negatives of each set of values, the positive values of each category become easier to affirm and integrate into our own positions.
By disclosing the presence of interdependent value polarities, polarity theory shows how the values we hold dear are almost always part of a complementary recursive system wherein the positive values of those we oppose are essential to the realization of our very own values. As an example, consider the interdependent polarity of modernism and postmodernism. Notwithstanding its rejection of modernity, postmodern culture depends on the free and prosperous social conditions created by modernism. And modernism in turn depends on the growth of postmodern values to help mitigate the environmental degradation that ultimately makes modernism unsustainable. Each pole therefore needs the other to help bring about the good that these opposing sets of values are ultimately trying to create. This approach to values integration can be stated as a general principle: When faced with a positive-positive value polarity, the best way to advance the values of our preferred pole is to actually affirm the foundational values of the pole we oppose.
When a positive-positive polarity is confused with a positive-negative dichotomy, the situation can become stuck or deadlocked. But when an authentic positive-positive polarity is managed according to this principle of complementary interdependence, a “stuck polarity” can become a “generative polarity”—a cooperative relationship of challenge and support that makes higher levels of agreement possible. Examples of how this principle works in the context of politics are discussed in the next section.
McIntosh, Steve. Developmental Politics: How America Can Grow Into a Better Version of Itself (pp. 58-62). (Function). Kindle Edition.
